| Fit Finlay | July 11, 1999 | Bash at the Beach | Fort Lauderdale, FL | 29 |
| Vacant | August 9, 1999 | Stripped due to Injury | Boise, ID | 104 |
| Norman Smiley | November 21, 1999 | Mayhem | Toronto, ON | 52 |
| Brian Knobbs | January 12, 2000 | Thunder | Erie, PA | 26 |
| Bam Bam Bigelow | February 7, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Tulsa, OK | 13 |
| Brian Knobbs (2) | February 20, 2000 | SuperBrawl 2000 | San Francisco, CA | 8 |
| 3 Count (Evan Karagias, Shane Helms & Shannon Moore) | February 28, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Minneapolis, MN | 20 |
| Brian Knobbs (3) | March 19, 2000 | Uncensored | Miami, FL | 22 |
| Vacant | April 10, 2000 | Title Vacated by Management | Denver, CO | 6 |
| Terry Funk | April 16, 2000 | Spring Stampede | Chicago, IL | 36 |
| Shane Douglas | May 22, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Grand Rapids, MI | 1 |
| Terry Funk (2) | May 23, 2000 | Thunder | Saginaw, MI | 13 |
| Eric Bischoff | June 5, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Atlanta, GA | 1 |
| The Mamalukes (Big Vito & Johnny The Bull) | June 6, 2000 | Thunder | Knoxville, TN | 13 |
| Big Vito (2) | June 19, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Billings, MT | 35 |
| Lance Storm | July 24, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Cleveland, OH | 21 |
| Carl Ouellet | August 14, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Kelowna, BC | 0 |
| Norman Smiley (2) | August 14, 2000 | Monday Nitro | Kelowna, BC | 44 |
| Vacant | September 27, 2000 | Vacated by Mike Sanders | Wilkes-Barre, PA | 5 |
| Reno | October 2, 2000 | Monday Nitro | San Francisco, CA | 37 |
| Crowbar | November 8, 2000 | Thunder | Chicago, IL | 39 |
| Terry Funk (3) | December 17, 2000 | Starrcade | Washington, D.C. | 28 |
| Meng | January 14, 2001 | Sin | Indianapolis, IN | 7 |
| Deactivated | January 21, 2001 | Title deactivated | | 346 |
| Activated | | Tommy Dreamer declared himself champion | | |
| Tommy Dreamer | January 2, 2002 | Velocity (January 5, 2002) | Waco, TX | Current |
